We Met At Acme

Lindsey Metselaar launched this show in 2017 with a focus on modern dating that has kept it relevant as the landscape shifted from Tinder culture to the age of situationships. The name comes from a real bar in New York, and that specific, grounded energy carries through the whole show. Lindsey interviews dating experts, therapists, and regular people about their relationship experiences, and she mixes in solo episodes where she shares her own stories with disarming honesty. Produced by Dear Media, the show has built up 445 episodes over the years. Each one runs about 40 minutes to just over an hour, making them easy to fit into a commute or workout. Lindsey's interview style is curious without being pushy -- she asks the follow-up questions you'd want to ask a friend. Topics range from attachment styles and navigating different love languages to harder conversations about fertility, finances in relationships, and how to know when to walk away. The show has evolved alongside Lindsey's own life. She recently became a mother and has been candid about how that shifted her perspective on relationships and identity. With a 4.2-star rating from 2,400 reviews, the audience appreciates her blend of practical advice and personal vulnerability. She also weaves in astrology content for listeners who are into that. If you're in your twenties trying to make sense of modern dating without losing your mind, this show feels like getting advice from a smart older sister who has been through it.