The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman

Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman spent years competing against each other as Yankees beat writers before teaming up for The Show, a weekly baseball podcast from the New York Post. Between them, they bring over three decades of clubhouse access, front office relationships, and insider sourcing that most podcast hosts simply cannot match. The show drops every Tuesday and typically runs 45 minutes to just over an hour, with a format that mixes the two hosts debating current MLB storylines with interviews from the people making the news. Recent guests have included Scott Boras discussing free agency strategy, Cubs GM Jed Hoyer on landing Alex Bregman, and reliever Luke Weaver on his move to the Mets. Those are not softball conversations either. Sherman and Heyman push back on their guests and on each other, which makes the discussions feel more honest than the typical promotional circuit interview. With 191 episodes since 2022 and a 4.8-star rating from over 200 reviews, the show has found a loyal audience that values the insider access. The New York angle is unavoidable given the hosts backgrounds, but they cover the full league and are especially strong during the offseason when trades and signings dominate the news cycle. If you want to hear from the reporters who are actually breaking MLB stories rather than just reacting to them, The Show delivers that perspective week after week.