My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

My Favorite Murder essentially created the true crime comedy genre when Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark started recording in 2016. The concept is simple: two friends sit down, each tells the other about a murder or crime that fascinates them, and they react in real time with a mix of horror, humor, and genuine empathy. It sounds like it shouldn't work, but over 1,100 episodes and 170,000 Apple Podcasts ratings later, the formula clearly resonates. Karen is a comedian and writer, Georgia a television personality, and their dynamic feels genuinely unscripted. They go on tangents about their personal lives, their cats, their therapy sessions — and then pivot seamlessly into the details of a serial killer case. The phrase "Stay Sexy and Don't Get Murdered" became a cultural catchphrase and the title of their bestselling book. The show spawned the Exactly Right podcast network, which now produces dozens of shows across true crime, comedy, and pop culture. MFM itself releases episodes twice a week, including full-length episodes and "minisodes" featuring listener-submitted hometown crime stories. The community aspect — the "Murderino" fanbase — has become its own phenomenon with local meetup groups and fan conventions. At a 4.6-star rating, the show maintains strong audience support despite being nearly a decade old. The early episodes are looser and rougher around the edges, while recent seasons feature tighter production and more researched cases. It's not for purists who want strict factual reporting, but for people who want to process dark subject matter with humor and humanity, MFM practically invented the space.