What Was That Like

What Was That Like asks one simple question and then lets the answer unfold for an hour. Hosts Scott Johnson and Meredith Hackwith Edwards sit down with ordinary people who lived through extraordinary events and ask them to walk through every detail. Animal attacks, plane crashes, hostage situations, mass shootings, natural disasters. The guests tell their own stories in their own words, and the result is gripping in a way that scripted drama rarely achieves. The show has built up 470 episodes over the years, earning a 4.7-star rating from nearly 1,700 reviewers. Johnson has a calm, sincere interview style that puts guests at ease, which matters enormously when someone is recounting the worst day of their life. He asks the specific questions you'd want to ask: What did it smell like? What were you thinking in that exact moment? How did your body react? New episodes drop biweekly, with bonus "Tuesday Question" segments and "Short True Stories" filling the gaps between main episodes. The main stories are the real draw, though. Each one reads like a survival memoir compressed into podcast form. There's a premium tier called What Was That Like PLUS for ad-free listening and exclusive bonus content. The free version works fine, and the show has an explicit content rating given the nature of the stories. If you want first-person accounts of the kind of situations you hope never happen to you, this podcast delivers them with remarkable consistency.