Overthinking It

Overthinking It has been running since 2008, which makes it ancient by podcast standards, and its 938 episodes represent one of the longest-running pop culture analysis shows anywhere. The premise is straightforward: subject popular culture to a level of scrutiny it probably does not deserve. The hosts break down TV shows, movies, Super Bowl halftime performances, and viral trends with a semi-scholarly enthusiasm that somehow never feels pretentious. Recent episodes have analyzed Bad Bunny halftime show choices, the film Sinners, and social media climbing culture through the lens of business theory. The show has a 4.8 rating from 263 reviewers, and longtime listeners describe the experience as hanging out with old friends -- one reviewer mentioned listening to every single episode since 2013. The biweekly format gives the hosts time to actually think about their analysis rather than rushing out hot takes, and you can feel that preparation in the conversations. If your version of overthinking involves spending three hours after a movie constructing theories about what the director really meant, or rewatching a TV scene to catch symbolism nobody else noticed, this is your people. The hosts turn the overthinking impulse into something genuinely entertaining and occasionally brilliant.