Mysterious Universe

Running since 2006, Mysterious Universe is one of the longest-standing mystery podcasts out there, and it has gone through a notable evolution. The show recently transitioned to new hosts Joe Hodgdon and Brandon Thomas after original hosts Benjamin Grundy and Aaron Wright stepped away in late 2025. That said, the format remains intact: weekly episodes tackling everything from UFO encounters and consciousness research to cryptozoology, alternative history, and what the show cheerfully calls new-age absurdity. The tone is conversational and often funny, with the hosts bouncing ideas off each other rather than lecturing. They cover recent paranormal news, review books, and occasionally interview researchers working on the fringes of accepted science. The show also offers a Plus+ subscription tier with extended episodes and bonus material for listeners who want to go deeper. Episodes are explicit-rated, reflecting a casual approach that includes occasional strong language. With a 4.5-star rating from over 5,500 reviews, it has clearly built a devoted following. The free weekly episodes offer a solid taste, though the premium feed is where the longer, more freewheeling discussions live. Expect a show that takes its weird subject matter seriously but never takes itself too seriously.