Murder With My Husband

Murder With My Husband has a premise that sounds like a sitcom pitch: Payton Moreland is obsessed with true crime, and her husband Garrett wants nothing to do with it. So naturally they made a podcast together. Payton researches and presents each case while Garrett listens and reacts as someone who would honestly rather be doing anything else. That tension -- one host deeply invested, the other slightly horrified -- creates a dynamic that feels surprisingly natural and entertaining. The show has grown into a legitimate force since launching, with over 440 episodes and a presence across Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, Twitch, and even Netflix. New episodes come out weekly. Payton handles the storytelling with clear, well-organized summaries of each case, and Garrett's reactions range from genuine shock to dark humor. Their dog Daisy makes occasional cameo appearances and has become something of a mascot among listeners. With a 4.8-star rating from nearly 18,000 reviews, the audience clearly connects with the husband-and-wife format. It works because the relationship feels real -- there is playful bickering, inside jokes, and moments where Garrett genuinely cannot believe what he is hearing. The show covers a wide range of cases, from well-known headline crimes to stories you have probably never encountered. If you want true crime that feels like eavesdropping on a couple's very specific date night, this one nails it.