Monsters Among Us

Launched by Derek Hayes in 2015, Monsters Among Us has grown into one of the most popular call-in paranormal shows on the internet, stacking up more than 600 public episodes across over 20 seasons. The core hook is simple and effective: instead of hosts reading Reddit threads, everyday witnesses call the show's hotline and tell their strange encounters in their own voices.
Hayes curates each roughly hour-long episode twice a week around recurring themes and listener recordings. One night might feature eerie tales of faceless entities, phantom music, and zooming orbs of light; another marks the 60th anniversary of Mothman sightings, collects callers' Dogman and werewolf encounters, or revisits haunted hotels and Ouija board stories. Hayes frames each call with brief historical background, folklore parallels, or skeptical observations, keeping the mood unsettling without tipping into melodrama.
The nostalgia-heavy production, subtle synth beds, and late-night radio atmosphere give Monsters Among Us a distinct identity that feels like stumbling across a weird AM broadcast on a desert highway. Hearing tremor, hesitation, and genuine confusion in a caller's own voice adds weight that scripted narration rarely matches. For fans of ghost stories, cryptids, UFO sightings, and unexplained roadside encounters told directly by eyewitnesses, Monsters Among Us is a dependable staple.
Are you the host or producer of Monsters Among Us?
Pin your show to the featured spot at the top of Paranormal Podcasts starting at $49.
Latest Episodes
No episodes available at this time.


