Divided Argument

Divided Argument bills itself as an unscheduled, unpredictable Supreme Court podcast, and after seven seasons and 140 episodes, that description still holds. Hosted by constitutional law professors Will Baude of the University of Chicago and Dan Epps of Washington University in St. Louis in partnership with SCOTUSblog, the show feels like eavesdropping on two former Supreme Court clerks arguing over coffee.
Episodes typically run an hour or longer and focus heavily on what most general-interest legal shows skip: unsigned shadow-docket orders, procedural quirks, statutory interpretation puzzles, and doctrinal tensions buried in footnotes. Recent episodes take on everything from Purcell principle election stays and Article III standing in Trump v. California to Alien Tort Statute limits in Cisco Systems v. Doe and Equal Protection rulings on state sports laws.
Because Baude leans conservative-originalist while Epps brings a more liberal-pragmatist instinct, their disagreements are genuine and intellectually sharp without ever turning theatrical. They also keep things surprisingly lighthearted, weaving in listener mailbag questions, jokes about their own prediction scorecards, and occasional nerdy detours. You do not need a law degree to enjoy Divided Argument, though it definitely assumes you care about the mechanics of judicial reasoning. For lawyers, law students, and serious Court watchers, few podcasts match its depth.
Are you the host or producer of Divided Argument?
Pin your show to the featured spot at the top of Law Podcasts starting at $49.
Latest Episodes
No episodes available at this time.


