5-4

Most podcasts about the Supreme Court treat the justices like solemn umpires calling balls and strikes. 5-4 throws that polite fiction out the window. Hosted by lawyers Peter Shamshiri, Rhiannon Hamam, and Michael Liroff and produced by Prologue Projects, the show examines landmark rulings and current docket fights from an unabashedly progressive, sharply funny perspective.
Across more than 330 weekly episodes usually running 40 to 50 minutes, the hosts read closely from actual majority opinions and dissents, then show how political ideology, institutional cowardice, or bad-faith reasoning shaped the outcome. Recent episodes tackle everything from Lyng v. Northwest Indian Cemetery Protective Association, where the Court cleared the way for a Forest Service road across sacred indigenous land, to Minersville School District v. Gobitis and fast-moving immigration detention cases like DHS v. D.V.D.
What keeps 5-4 grounded despite its irreverent, occasionally profane humor is that all three hosts know the doctrine cold. They quote oral argument transcripts, point out where a justice quietly rewrote precedent, and explain legal concepts like standing or substantive due process without putting non-lawyers to sleep. You also get timely reaction episodes on major elections and federal prosecutions alongside deep historical case studies. If you want rigorous Supreme Court analysis that refuses to pretend legal formalism is neutral, 5-4 has earned its huge following.
Are you the host or producer of 5-4?
Pin your show to the featured spot at the top of Law Podcasts starting at $49.
Latest Episodes
No episodes available at this time.


