My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark turned true crime fandom into a cultural movement when they launched My Favorite Murder in January 2016. The formula sounds like it shouldn't work: two comedians casually discussing serial killers, cold cases, and cults while cracking jokes and going on personal tangents. But it absolutely does, and over 1,100 episodes later, the Murderino community they've built is massive and fiercely loyal. The show's format alternates between full episodes where Karen and Georgia each present a case, and shorter "minisodes" featuring listener-submitted hometown crime stories. Full episodes can run up to an hour and 40 minutes, while minisodes clock in around 20 minutes. Karen brings the polished comedy writer's instinct for pacing and punchlines. Georgia's strength is her emotional honesty and willingness to say what everyone's thinking. Together they create a space where it's okay to be fascinated by dark subjects without being ghoulish about it. They openly discuss their own struggles with anxiety, addiction, and mental health, which gives the show a vulnerability that pure comedy or pure true crime podcasts lack. For car rides, MFM works because the conversational tone makes it feel like you've got two funny friends in the passenger seat. The show is explicit and occasionally intense in its subject matter, so it's best suited for adult listeners. With 170,000+ ratings and a 4.6-star average, this one has clearly resonated with a lot of people.